Menelaus theorem proof pdf

The proof that we give of the hyperbolic version of that theorem works as well. If line intersecting on, where is on, is on the extension of, and on the intersection of and, then. Most geometry references, however, cite this theorem for plane geometry as menelaus s theorem. Exploring menelaus theorem in hilbert geometry math in. Bb1 and cc1 of a triangle abc figure 2 are concurrent if and only if. We prove that the well known ceva and menelaus theorems are both. Consider the triangle aa1c and apply menelaus the orem. Let d, e and f be menelaus points on sides bc, ac and ab respectively of abc. Menelaus theorem for quadrilaterals in the poincar. The planes determined by pairs of rays, and go through the same ray if and only if. A proof for a property which generalizes the menelaus theorem from triangles to pentagrams. Solutions to ceva and menelaus problems math 324 r. For the love of physics walter lewin may 16, 2011 duration.

T oday, we have shown how to use menelaus theorem effectively to prove the pascals magical theorem. This will help develop creativity and written communication skills. Cevas theorem is essentially the counterpart of this theorem and can be used to prove three lines are. If this is true, cevas theorem says that the lines are concurrent. Cevas theorem and menelauss theorem have proofs by barycentric coordinates, which is e ectively a form of projective geometry. Dec 31, 2014 for the love of physics walter lewin may 16, 2011 duration. Let the sides opposite the corresponding vertices be the arcs, and contain the points. In a discussion on the menelaus theorem we presented two proofs. The theorem gives a necessary and sufficient condition for the concurrency of three cevians. We begin with the recall of some basic geometric notions and properties in the poincar. The product of three nonadjacent segments is equal to the product of the other three.

Crossratio proof gre57 1 introduction in their most basic form, cevas theorem and menelauss theorem are simple formulas of triangle geometry. A point p on the line ab is said to divide the segment ab in the ratio ap. Cevas and menelaus theorems for the ndimensional space. Most geometry references, however, cite this theorem for plane geometry as menelauss theorem. Its name is in honor of the scottish mathematician matthew stewart who published the theorem in 1746 when he was believed to be a candidate to replace colin maclaurin as professor of mathematics. The only problem is dealing with ratios of distances, because when we change points to lines, distance doesnt make much sense. Not long ago i came across a post an ugly and an elegant proof of menelaus theorem by antreas p.

Journal for geometry and graphics volume 4 2000, no. For either of these diagrams, we have menelaus theorem. There are other cases possible, all of which can be proven using a similar method q. If abc is a triangle and pqr is a straight line that cuts ab, ca, and the extension of bc at p, q, and r respectively, then 1 explanation of menelaus theorem. Cevas theorem the three lines containing the vertices a, b, and c of abc and intersecting opposite sides at points l, m, and n, respectively, are concurrent if and only if m l n b c a p an bl cm 1 nb malc 21sept2011 ma 341 001 2. The students will be placed in pairs to help them learn to cooperate and help one another through self discovery and the cooperative activity. Conversely, if the points d, e, and fon the extensions of the sides of a triangle have their ratios multiply to 1 as above, the points are collinear.

In their most basic form, cevas theorem and menelauss theorem are simple formulas of. Since k 61,points x and y can be found on the line ab satisfying the above conditions. We note that triangles have the same altitude to line, but bases and. The proof of the above result is similar to the proof of the converse of evas theorem as given in 1. Menelaus theorem article about menelaus theorem by the. Menelaus s theorem, named for menelaus of alexandria, is a proposition about triangles in plane geometry. A pdf copy of the article can be viewed by clicking below. Pdf a unified proof of ceva and menelaus theorems using.

T oday we will learn about two wellknown theorems in geometry, cevas theorem and menelaus theorem. To prove menelaus from ceva requires using ceva six times. The converse is useful in proving that three points are collinear. On menelaus theorem singapore mathematical society nus. Again, theres a few things from the diagram for the proof of the theorem that are no longer present, but since theyre not used in the final proof, they were extraneous anyway. What is a cevian in one triangle is a transversal in another. Cevas and menelaus theorems characterize the hyperbolic geometry among hilbert geometries. Both of the theorems will be proved based on a common simple principle. Cevas and menelaus theorems for the ndimensional space 117 3. Menelaus theorem, clifford configurations and inversive geometry of the schwarzian kp hierarchy article pdf available in journal of physics a general physics 3529 may 2001 with 80 reads.

Menelauss theorem, named for menelaus of alexandria, is a proposition about triangles in. Since the copy is a faithful reproduction of the actual journal pages, the article may not begin at the top of the first page. Note that the above proof is valid for one case only. Cevas and menelaus theorems characterize the hyperbolic. In this video, we look at how to prove menelaus theorem that is used to show three points are collinear. Menelaus theorem definition is a theorem in geometry. The theorems of ceva and menelaus pdf book manual free download. Menelaus theorem completed by several arabic mathematicians. The converse of menelaus theorem is very useful in showing the collinearity of three given points on a plane. There are several different proofs of menelaus theorem. Notethat px and py are respectively the internal and external bisectors of angle apb. Department of mathematics ataturk university erzurum, turkey corresponding author email. We will use the notation to denote the area of a triangle with vertices. Alternatively, when written with directed segments, the theorem becomes proofs proof with similar triangles.

The theorems of ceva and menelaus pdf book manual free. Pdf we prove that the well known ceva and menelaus theorems are both particular cases of a single theorem of projective geometry. Menelaus theorem relates ratios obtained by a line cutting the sides of a triangle. Other articles where menelaus theorem is discussed. Thus, we have completed the proof of pascals theorem. And like i said, there should be a joint approach using duality. Under the conditions above, the product of the ratios af fb bd dc ce ea 1. First assume that the cevians are con current at the point m. Through e, draw a parallel to ad which intersects ac in g and the extension of ab at f. We leave the proof of the above resu it to the reader. Menelaus theorem, named for menelaus of alexandria, is a theorem about triangles in plane geometry.

In other words, cevas theorem is related to the sides and vertices of a triangle. In this study, we present a proof of the menelaus theorem for quadrilaterals in hyperbolic geometry, and a proof for the transversal theorem for triangles. A new proof of menelauss theorem of hyperbolic quadrilaterals in the poincare model of hyperbolic geometry florentin smarandache1 and ca ta lin barbu2 1 department of mathematics, university of new mexico, gallup, nm 87301, usa. Its name is in honor of the scottish mathematician matthew stewart who published the theorem in 1746 when he was believed to be a candidate to replace colin maclaurin as professor of mathematics at. In 1 has been given proof of this theorem, but to use kleins model of hyperbolic geometry. Given a triangle abc, and a transversal line that crosses bc, ac and ab at points d, e and f respectively, with d, e, and f distinct from a, b and. Menelauss theorem, named for menelaus of alexandria, is a proposition about triangles in plane geometry. The students will work individually on journal prompts.

In the detail, the author, after having proven in general menelaus s theorem for. However, these theorems characterize a projec tive property concurrence in cevas theorem and collinearity in menelaus theorem in terms of an affine property. For plane geometry, the theorem of menelaus is given any line that transverses crosses the three sides of a triangle one of them will have to be extended, six segments are cut off on the sides. Oct 25, 20 description of proof of menelaus s theorem micah james. The form of this theorem for plane triangles, well known to his contemporaries, was expressed as follows. The proof using rouths theorem is extremely trivial, so we will not include it. Indeed, menelaus theorem is a very useful tool often employed to prove the collinearity of points.

Today, we will use menelaus theorem to prove pascals theorem for the circle case. Given a triangle abc with points x, y, z on the side lines bc, ca, abrespectively, the points x, y, z are collinear if and only if bx xc cy ya az zb. So, you just need to know what cevas theorem is, its formula and application, not the derivation of the theorem. Cevas and menelaus theorems for the ndimensional space malgorzata bubabrzozowa. The menelaus theorem gives a necessary and sufficient condition for three points one on each side of a triangle to lie on a transversal. Draw a spherical triangle on the surface of a unit sphere centered at.

Multiplying the two equalities together to eliminate the factor, we get. Given a triangle abc, let the lines ao, bo and co be drawn from the vertices to a common point o not on one of the sides of abc, to meet opposite sides at d, e and f respectively. If a1b1a2b2a3b3a4b4a5b5is a pentagram, then for the proof we repeatedly use menelaus theorem, which states that if a line. In the detail, the author, after having proven in general menelauss theorem for. In geometry, stewarts theorem yields a relation between the side lengths and a cevian length of a triangle. It can be proved from the law of cosines as well as by the famous pythagorean theorem. Also, we will give a reciprocal hyperbolic version of this theorem. Given a triangle abc with points x, y, z on the side lines bc, ca, ab respectively, the points x, y, z are collinear if and only if. The menelaus theorem gives a necessary and sufficient condition for three points one on each side of a triangle. I am not understanding completely the last affermation of the following proof of the converse of menelaus s theorem. A menelaustype theorem for the pentagram mathematical.

Jun 06, 2014 menelaus theorem, named for menelaus of alexandria, is a theorem about triangles in plane geometry. Description of proof of menelauss theorem micah james. On hyperbolic analogues of some classical theorems in spherical. Here is the proof of fermats little theorem theorem1. Return to menelaus theorem, and introduce barycentric coordinates based on the original. Cevas theorem and menelauss theorem are actually equivalent.

A straight line is often called a transversal to emphasize its relation to another shape. A unified proof of ceva and menelaus theorems using projective. These two theorems are very useful in plane geometry because we often use them to prove that a certain number of points lie on a straight line and a certain number of lines intersect at a single point. Menelaus and cevas theorem for spherical triangle wolfram. Menelaus produced an analogous theorem for spherical geometry. Eulers theorem has a proof that is quite similar to the proof of fermats little theorem.

Now, ar is an angle bisector, so the angle bisector theorem says br ab rc ac. The theorem for the geometry of the plane was known before menelaus. Exploring menelaus theorem in hilbert geometry math in action. If a hilbert geometry satisfies a rather weak version of either cevas or menelaus theorem for every triangle.

Cevas theorem states that given any triangle abc, the segments from a, b, and c to the opposite sides of the triangle are concurrent precisely when the product of the ratios of the pairs of segments formed on each side of the triangle is equal to 1. We, however, claiming as we do a greater share in wis. Cevas theorem is a theorem about triangles in plane geometry. Serving as a connection between modern and historical geometries, menelaus theorem has certain applications in higherlevel mathematics. Menelaus theorem deals with the collinearity of points on each of the three sides extended when necessary of a triangle. Let bd be the diagonal of quadrilateral,which divides it into two triangles, we use menelaustheorem for triangles abd and bcd,so. A unified proof of ceva and menelaus theorems using projective geometry article pdf available in journal for geometry and graphics 111. Three or more line segments in the plane are concurrent if they have a common point of intersection. Given a triangle abc, and a transversal line that crosses bc, ac, and ab at points d, e, and f respectively, with d, e, and f distinct from a, b, and c, then. Menelaus theorem definition of menelaus theorem by.